Honest to Goodness - Organic Marketing Australia Pty Ltd fighting Woolworths over their use of the phrase 'Honest to Goodness'
SEO AustraliaSEO

Honest to Goodness - ANOTHER trademark dispute?

Follow JustWeb on Twitter
Visit JustWeb's Facebook page

Follow Me on Pinterest


31 visitors are currently online at justweb®

WOMO review

SEO

Search Engine Optimisation (Search Engine Optimisation)
Statistics show us that more than 80% of traffic from search engines comes from organic results. Basically, unless you are on the first page of Google™, regardless if you have a PPC strategy, your website may not be performing to it's full potential. For experienced, proven SEO Australia results, contact us today about website audits, SEO, and how we can improve your organic search engine optimisation with proven results.

Copywriting

Website Copywriting A good copywriter knows which words trigger the feelings that compel people to make decisions. They write with flair, making it easy for people to be drawn into what they are saying about your business, services or products. Read an an example of good copywriting for a fictitious Sydney Mercedes Dealer, or just "ok" website copy for a Used Mercedes dealer.

Trademarks

Trademark Registration The most effective way to safeguard you against people "trading off" your business name, product or service, is to register a trademark. For more information, including about the justweb® trade mark, please read our trademark registration article.

Bookmark and Share

W3C Validated: XHTML | CSS

News, Blog and Article index page
Yet again, another David versus Goliath fight looms over a trademark issue.

But, rather than it being a case of a big corporation throwing their weight around against a mere speck on the business horizon, this time it's the small organic food company Organic Marketing Australia Pty Ltd with their branding "Honest to Goodness", located in Artarmon, Sydney, versus the huge Woolworths company.

It seems that Woolworths are using the phrase "Honest to Goodness" to promote their new family meals, with Margaret Fulton as the face of the line.

Honest to Goodness Trademark

Update: 31 March 2011 (display update ∇)


The Woolworths decision to use "Honest to Goodness" could have come about in one of two ways (in my opinion):

1) Their lawyers checked out the logo trademark registered in 2004 by Organic Marketing Australia Pty Ltd, and decided it was not strong enough to hold up if the owner ever decided to legally challenge them. Note it was a logo trademark, not a word trademark.

2) Someone may have screwed up on the Woolworths side and didn't do the required trademark and domain name searches.

To be honest, it is unlikely the reason was #2, especially looking at the various trademark filings earlier in March (2011).

Several things to note here are that it looks like Organic Marketing Australia Pty Ltd may have prepared and filed their logo trademark on their own to get registration in 2004. Yet in early March 2011 they employed the services of a well known law firm to register their word trademark (HONEST TO GOODNESS) and this time they also slightly changed their description of services.

This evidence suggests their lawyers are seeking to improve the quality of legal rights claimed by Organic Marketing Australia Pty Ltd and their branding, Honest To Goodness,  in the earlier registration so it more accurately represents what Organic Marketing Australia Pty Ltd (http://www.goodness.com.au/) do, rather than what they intended to do when they first established.

I'm a big advocate of trademarks, and often they are your best form of protecting the name of your business, products, or services. But things are not always black and white: there are dark greys and light greys as well!

An example of a straight forward situation (black and white) might be perhaps if a company decided to build a line of retail stores called "Honest to Goodness". It might also be a straightforward case if a company decided to create a food product (or something else covered by the "Honest to Goodness" 2004 registered trademark).

Dark grey might be using the "Honest to Goodness" phrase as a tagline, and light grey might be simply referencing the expression "Honest to Goodness" in text or spoken word in an advertisement.

One test here is, whether the present dispute involves trademark use by Woolies, or alternatively, mere use by Woolies of "Honest to Goodness" as a description of their services.

You decide - check out the dedicated Woolies website: http://www.woolworthshonesttogoodness.com.au.

IP Attorney, Noric Dilanchian of Dilanchian Lawyers & Consultants draws valuable lessons from the current dispute.
"High value marketing campaigns should always involve a greater level of caution in trade marks search work and general IP law checks. TV advertising campaigns are an example of when this caution is prudent.

"There is in these cases an economic imperative. It is that so much money is spent in such a short time period and it flies or dies on the availability for use of an image, name, tag line or other identifier.

"Intellectual property law case books are strewn with examples of advertisers caught in impending mid-air collisions. On the one side the company with an ad to run has already sunk costs for preparing and scheduling a major ad campaign. On the other side, an opponent suddenly enters the radar screen claiming greater or prior monopoly legal rights to a trade mark, common law supporting a reputation or goodwill or copyright in an image. The opponent typically sends an initial demand letter and, failing compliance with it, seeks an injunction in court action.

"The company with an ad to run is usually on the back foot and must make immediate judgement calls. There's little time to make a decision. They have at least three unhappy options. First, stop the marketing campaign and waste the dollars spent. Second, negotiate to run the ad in return for money and other conditions required by the opponent. Third, rely on its economic muscle and defend with claimed legal rights.

"These unhappy options can be avoided if high value marketing campaigns are designed and undertaken only after thorough trade mark searches and general IP law checks.

Summary

Registered Trademark My advice is, register a trademark. If you can't afford the services of a competent and experienced IP Attorney, by all means, register a TM yourself. BUT, as soon as you have the funds, get an IP Attorney to look it over and check for "leaks" and areas for improvement. Legal costs are always going to be much greater if you do this after your competitor's horses have bolted.

Your self-registered trademark may look fine to you, and it may pass initial scrutinisation, but without expert advice you may be leaving big holes in your protective legal armour.

Finally, if you do register a trademark, make sure it is CLEAR that it is registered on your website, stationery and packaging - use the ® symbol to make it known. You must also ensure that the trademark you registered matches what you use in your business. Otherwise, any action you decide to bring will be more complex and costly.

At justweb®, we use and recommend the services of:

Dilanchian Lawyers & Consultants
The University Centre, 210 Clarence Street
Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel (02) 9269 0229
Email Noric Dilanchian
Web www.dilanchian.com.au

More information

Trademark Registration | Business Name Trademark | Trademark Symbol
justweb® Statutory Law Rights

Has this article been helpful or interesting?
Why not share it with others? Simply place your mouse over the buttons below to select from a range of social media websites, and thanks for sharing.



Click here to make an enquiry   Follow JustWeb on Twitter


Rob - JustWeb

21.03.2011


back to Newsletter Index

justweb® Newsletter Information
The articles throughout our website are ©2007-2017 justweb® and may not be reproduced without first seeking permission. If you want to be updated on a regular basis, please subscribe to our RSS feed.

Subscribe to the justweb® feed by email:



DISCLAIMER:
The content provided in this article is provided as is, and as such does not carry a warranty or guarantee by justweb® that it will provide results discussed. The article content provided is intended for informational purposes in order to introduce readers to new ideas, concepts, and/or reviews of new products and/or services. It is incumbent upon the reader to do further research before acting upon any advice or suggestions in this article. It is a condition of reading our articles that justweb® will not be held liable for any negative consequences that may result from the implementation of any information or purchases made as a result of reading this article.



Website Hosting

For fast & reliable web hosting Australia, we use & recommend the services of Quadra Hosting.

Web Hosting Australia Online Spell Checker Press Release Distribution Pay Per Click Advertising Business Alliance Partners

Read what some of our clients have to say about justweb®

^ Top of Page ^